Review Guidelines

IMJETA values the role of reviewers in the peer-review process that enables us to publish high-quality materials in a timely way.

The reviewers are highly qualified academics and scientists, for this, IMJETA value their ethics and confidentiality to:

    - Maintain the principle of impartiality and respect for gender identity, nationality, race, religion and belief, as well as non-discrimination of any kind.
    - To declare any conflicts of interest before beginning the review.
    - To keep the entire content of the article confidential.
    - Not use data, ideas, or results from the article before publication.
    - To accept for review only articles in which they have sufficient expertise.
    - Submit their reviews using the online form provided on the portal.
    - To provide a clear recommendation and justifications for their recommendation for either acceptance or rejection of an article.
    - Make clear, respectful and constructive observations.

Reviewers should consider:

       Relevance and Originality
             - The topic is relevant to the journal's scope.
             - The work provides new insights or a novel approach.
             - The literature review is up-to-date and properly cited.

       Methodology
             - The methodology is appropriate to address the objectives or hypotheses.
             - Procedures and samples are described in sufficient detail for replication.
             - Data analysis is correct and well justified.

       Clarity and Structure
             - The manuscript is well-structured (Introduction, Methodology, Results, Discussion, Conclusions).
             - The language is clear, precise, and free from grammatical errors.
             - Tables, figures, and charts are relevant, properly labeled, and well presented.

       Results and Conclusions
             - The results are presented objectively.
             - The conclusions are supported by the data and analyzes presented.
             - Theoretical and/or practical implications are discussed.

       Compliance with Guidelines
             - The manuscript follows the journal's formatting and citation guidelines.
             - There is no evidence of plagiarism or self-plagiarism.
             - Images and data comply with publication ethics.

       Final Recommendation
             - Accept
             - Accept with minor revisions
             - Resubmit for review
             - Reject